Florida Couple Says Server Tried to Add Another Table’s Unpaid Bill to Their Check During Date Night at Sparrow Restaurant
FLORIDA — What was supposed to be a relaxing date night at an upscale restaurant turned into a viral controversy after a Florida couple alleged their server tried to charge them for another table’s unpaid bill.
TikTok user Jo (@theycallme_jo_) posted a video recounting her experience at Sparrow, a popular rooftop restaurant and cocktail bar in Fort Lauderdale. Her clip — which has now surpassed 31,000 views — shows her sitting in her car, frustrated and calling out the restaurant’s management for what she says was a dishonest move.
“I need for you guys to check the integrity of your staff, because they literally tried to get us last night,” Jo said in the now-viral video.
The Alleged Overcharge
Jo said she and her husband had been enjoying their evening when they received their bill. “We don’t really look at the bill sometimes. We’ll just pay and then go to put the tip,” she explained. But when her husband went to confirm the amount, something seemed off — the recommended tip amount was nearly double what they expected.
After checking the itemized receipt, they realized another table’s bill had been added to theirs. When they brought it up, the waitress reportedly apologized, claiming there had been a “computer error” that merged two tables.
“She’s like, ‘Oh, I’m so sorry about that. Someone left. They didn’t pay their bill, so the computer accidentally joined the two tables,’” Jo recounted. “No, you’re trying to be slick.”
Jo alleged the server attempted to make them cover the cost of a walk-out table — something she believes the waitress would have been held financially responsible for. “You’re lucky my husband left you a tip, ’cause he shouldn’t have,” she said.
Can Servers Be Forced to Pay for Walk-Outs?
The video reignited debate online about restaurant policies and how businesses handle “dine and dash” situations. According to the U.S. Department of Labor, it is illegal for employers to require servers to pay for walk-out losses if doing so brings their total earnings below the federal tipped minimum wage of $2.13 per hour.
However, practices vary widely across restaurants, and some servers report being pressured into covering unpaid tabs. On the r/ServerLife subreddit, many industry workers shared that while it’s technically unlawful, some managers still enforce it indirectly.
“It’s illegal. No, you don’t HAVE to pay for walk-outs. But restaurants can ‘write you up’ for small mistakes until they can fire you,” one user explained.
“I was set up by scammers to go get dessert, and when I came back, they were gone. Management wanted me to pay, but my coworkers told me to take the write-up instead,” another recalled.
Industry Reactions and Viewer Opinions
Jo’s video quickly drew responses from both restaurant workers and diners, with many divided over whether the mix-up was an honest mistake or intentional.
“I’m a server — this can happen if someone rings the wrong table or opens two tabs by mistake,” one commenter wrote.
But others weren’t convinced: “Ain’t no POS system ‘accidentally’ combining tables!!” another user insisted.
Several viewers reminded Jo to always check receipts carefully before paying, saying that overlooking itemized details can lead to overcharges. “Always, always have a general idea of the total bill … it’s only on you if you overpay,” one person commented.
Jo agreed, replying, “Very true. Can’t be so relaxed.”
@theycallme_jo_ You thought!
The Restaurant’s Response
As of publication, neither Sparrow Fort Lauderdale nor its management has issued a public statement. BroBible reached out to both Jo and the restaurant for comment but had not received a response.
The incident serves as a reminder for diners to double-check their bills and for restaurants to maintain transparency — especially when digital systems or staff errors can easily create costly misunderstandings.
For now, Jo’s video stands as both a cautionary tale and a viral lesson in consumer awareness.
Have you ever had a restaurant overcharge you by mistake — or on purpose? Share your experience with us at NapervilleLocal.com.
I’ve lived in Naperville long enough to see how quickly our community changes — from new developments downtown to sudden shifts in our Midwest weather. Reporting on Naperville news and daily forecasts gives me the chance to keep neighbors informed about what really matters. My goal is simple: deliver clear, timely updates so you always know what’s happening in our city and what to expect from the skies above.