Indiana Teen Hailey Buzbee Found Dead After Disappearing Jan. 5 as Man She Met Online Faces Felony Evidence Charges, Report Says
INDIANA — Hailey Buzbee, a teen reported missing from her Indiana home on Jan. 5, has been found dead, according to details shared in a widely circulated report that also states a 39-year-old man was arrested on felony charges tied to evidence and illegal material involving a minor. The case has drawn national attention because investigators say the suspect had met the teen online, and his attorney claims he later led authorities to her body.
What’s been reported about the disappearance
The information provided indicates Buzbee disappeared from her Indiana home on Jan. 5. The report describes her as a missing teen and suggests the case quickly shifted from a search effort to a criminal investigation after authorities located her body.
Publicly available details in the provided post do not specify where she was found, how long she was missing before that discovery, or what investigators believe happened in the time between her disappearance and the recovery of her body.
Arrest details and what charges are filed
The report says Tyler Thomas, 39, was arrested and is facing felony charges related to “sexually oriented matter” pertaining to a minor and tampering with evidence. Those allegations are significant because they point to a case focused not only on the disappearance, but also on what police believe occurred in connection to digital material and the handling of potential evidence.
Based on the information shown, Thomas is not yet facing charges directly connected to Buzbee’s death. That distinction matters because it indicates the investigation may still be developing, with prosecutors potentially reviewing additional evidence before deciding whether to file more severe charges.
Attorney claim: “He led them to her body”
A key detail highlighted in the report is the claim from Thomas’s attorney that he led police to Buzbee’s body. The wording suggests a turning point in the investigation, but the provided material does not include the broader context—such as whether Thomas contacted authorities voluntarily, whether he was questioned first, or what evidence led investigators to him.
The report also states Thomas allegedly told police he picked up the missing teen after meeting her online. However, the information provided does not include additional confirmation about the platform used, how long the online contact lasted, or whether investigators believe anyone else was involved.
What remains unclear right now
With only the details shown in the provided post, several central questions remain unanswered, including the circumstances of Buzbee’s death, the location and timeline of events after Jan. 5, and whether additional charges are expected. Authorities typically release more information as autopsy findings are completed and investigative steps are finalized.
What do you think communities and parents should be doing to better protect teens from online contacts turning into real-world danger? Share your thoughts and follow ongoing public safety updates at NapervilleLocal.com.
Naperville is a community with stories that deserve to be told — both the serious ones about safety and justice, and the lighter ones that capture our culture and daily life. I focus on covering crime reports and court updates while also highlighting the traditions, events, and social trends that shape who we are. Through my reporting, I want to give readers a fuller picture of Naperville — the challenges we face and the character that keeps our city strong.