Jury Deliberates in Rapid City Murder Case of Ezekiel Mayweather, Accused in Killing of Esther Wolfe
RAPID CITY, South Dakota — After days of testimony and emotional courtroom exchanges, the fate of 24-year-old Ezekiel Mayweather now rests in the hands of the jury. Mayweather faces charges of aiding and abetting and conspiracy to commit first-degree murder in connection with the 2024 killing of Esther Wolfe.
Closing Arguments Delivered After Lengthy Trial
The jury began deliberations Wednesday afternoon following closing statements from both the prosecution and defense. The trial featured 40 witnesses and more than 155 pieces of evidence, making it one of Pennington County’s most closely watched murder cases of the year.
Prosecutors outlined Mayweather’s alleged role in planning and covering up the February 21, 2024, shooting along East North Street. They cited surveillance footage showing Mayweather at multiple locations tied to the crime, including one where he reportedly dropped off co-defendant Arkadius Wright shortly before the shooting.
The state also argued that Mayweather helped dispose of the murder weapon, linking him directly to the aftermath of Wolfe’s death.
Co-Defendant Accepted Plea Deal
Wright, originally charged with first-degree murder, pleaded guilty to manslaughter earlier this year. He admitted to shooting Wolfe and now faces up to life in prison when sentenced in December.
Prosecutors emphasized Wright’s plea as part of their evidence that Mayweather knew about and participated in the crime, while defense attorneys attacked the credibility of the deal.
Defense Questions Motives, Evidence Gaps
During closing arguments, Mayweather’s defense team urged jurors to doubt the reliability of state witnesses who received leniency in exchange for testimony. They also pointed to inconsistencies in witness statements and argued there was no concrete plan or evidence to prove a conspiracy.
“The state’s case is built on assumptions, not facts,” the defense told jurors. “There was no agreement, no intent, and no proof that Ezekiel Mayweather planned anyone’s death.”
Verdict Expected Soon
Jurors are now weighing the evidence to decide whether Mayweather will be convicted or cleared of the charges. The verdict could come as early as Thursday, depending on how long deliberations last.
For continuing updates on South Dakota crime, trials, and court decisions, follow NapervilleLocal.com.
Naperville is a community with stories that deserve to be told — both the serious ones about safety and justice, and the lighter ones that capture our culture and daily life. I focus on covering crime reports and court updates while also highlighting the traditions, events, and social trends that shape who we are. Through my reporting, I want to give readers a fuller picture of Naperville — the challenges we face and the character that keeps our city strong.