New York Father Pleads Guilty to Second-Degree Murder After Starving 5-Year-Old Daughter While Using Drugs

NEW YORK — A disturbing child abuse case that shocked investigators and neighbors has reached a major legal milestone after a New York father admitted responsibility for the death of his young daughter. Authorities say the child was left to starve for months while her father locked her inside a bedroom, surrounded by boxes of food he never allowed her to eat.

Guilty Plea Brings Closure in a Horrific Child Abuse Case

Robert S. Buskey Jr., 35, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in connection with the 2024 death of his 5-year-old daughter, Charlotte Buskey. Prosecutors confirmed that the plea comes after months of evidence detailing severe neglect, prolonged starvation, and extreme confinement.

Buskey now faces a potential sentence ranging from 27 years to life in prison, according to court records.

Investigators Describe a “House of Horrors”

Authorities entered the family’s residence on April 14, 2024, where they described finding conditions consistent with long-term abuse and neglect. Inside the home, Charlotte’s bedroom door was locked from the outside, preventing her from leaving or seeking help.

Multiple boxes of food were stacked outside the locked door, a detail investigators say underscored the deliberate nature of the neglect. Medical experts later determined the child had been severely malnourished for months before dying.

Charlotte’s body was found lying on a pack-and-play crib that she had physically outgrown, indicating she had been confined to a space not appropriate for her age or size.

Younger Sibling Found Alive in a Cage

In another disturbing discovery, investigators located Buskey’s 3-year-old son alive but confined inside a cage within the home. Authorities immediately removed the child and provided emergency care.

Prosecutors emphasized that both children had been denied medical attention, family contact, and basic care for an extended period of time.

Drug Use and Admission of Responsibility

During the investigation, Buskey admitted to officers that he spent much of his time using drugs and playing video games, neglecting his parental responsibilities. He reportedly told investigators that he “let” his daughter die, a statement prosecutors cited as central to the case.

Toxicology reports later revealed that both children tested positive for cocaine, further intensifying the severity of the charges.

A Case That Raises Broader Child Welfare Concerns

The case has drawn widespread outrage and renewed discussions about child welfare oversight, intervention failures, and warning signs of severe neglect. Prosecutors noted that the prolonged nature of the abuse suggests multiple missed opportunities for intervention. Sentencing is expected at a later court date.

What Happens Next

Buskey remains in custody as the court prepares for sentencing. The surviving child is now under protective care. If you suspect child abuse or neglect, authorities urge immediate reporting to local child protection services or law enforcement.

What are your thoughts on this case, and how can communities better protect vulnerable children? Share your perspective and continue the conversation at NapervilleLocal.com.